Susan Smith, the South Carolina woman convicted of murdering her two young sons, was denied parole for the second time following a hearing on November 19. The decision has renewed attention on her former boyfriend, Tom Findlay, whose relationship with Smith became a central issue during her 1995 murder trial. Prosecutors argued that Smith killed her children because she wanted to continue a romantic relationship with Findlay, who had made it clear that he did not want children.
Susan Smith’s former boyfriend was Tom Findlay, a businessman from Union, South Carolina, whom she dated while her marriage to David Smith was breaking down. Their relationship ended shortly before the October 1994 murders of her sons, Michael and Alexander. Findlay later testified against Smith, explaining how their romance ended and why he had decided they could not build a future together.
Who Was Susan Smith’s Boyfriend Tom Findlay?
Tom Findlay, also known as Thomas Findlay, was a businessman associated with a prominent family in Union, South Carolina.
His father owned Conso Products, a local textile-related business where Susan Smith worked as a secretary.
Findlay and Smith became romantically involved during a difficult period in her marriage to David Smith.
At the time of the murders, Findlay was 27 years old, while Susan was 23.
Their relationship attracted national attention after investigators discovered that Findlay had ended their romance shortly before Smith killed her children.
Although Findlay became an important witness in the criminal proceedings, he was not accused of participating in the murders.
He has largely remained outside public attention since the trial.
How Did Susan Smith and Tom Findlay Meet?
Susan Smith and Tom Findlay became acquainted through their connection to Conso Products in Union, South Carolina.
Smith worked at the company, which was owned by Findlay’s father.
Their professional connection eventually developed into a romantic relationship while Smith was experiencing problems in her marriage.
According to testimony presented during the 1995 trial, the couple dated intermittently.
Findlay believed Smith was moving toward a divorce from her husband, David.
However, their relationship became increasingly complicated as questions arose about her marital status and family responsibilities.
Findlay later testified that he did not want to become involved in raising another man’s children.
These concerns ultimately contributed to his decision to end the relationship.
Why Did Tom Findlay Break Up With Susan Smith?
Tom Findlay ended his relationship with Susan Smith because he did not want children and believed they were incompatible as long-term romantic partners.
In October 1994, he wrote Smith a letter explaining why he did not believe their relationship could continue.
The letter acknowledged several qualities he admired about her but explained that he was not prepared to take responsibility for children.
Findlay delivered the letter approximately one week before Michael and Alexander were killed.
During Smith’s murder trial, prosecutors presented the letter as evidence of her emotional state and possible motive.
Findlay testified that Smith had expressed strong feelings for him and had struggled with their separation.
However, the existence of the letter did not establish that Findlay had any involvement in the crime.
His role in the case was primarily that of a former romantic partner and prosecution witness.
Did Susan Smith Kill Her Children Because of Her Boyfriend?
Prosecutors argued that Susan Smith murdered her two sons because she believed they prevented her from having a relationship with Tom Findlay.
Her children were Michael Daniel Smith, who was three years old, and Alexander Tyler Smith, who was 14 months old.
On October 25, 1994, Smith allowed her car to roll into John D. Long Lake in South Carolina while both children remained strapped into their car seats.
She initially claimed that an unidentified man had stolen her vehicle with the children inside.
Her false account triggered a nationwide search and widespread media coverage.
After nine days, Smith confessed that the kidnapping story was untrue.
During her trial, prosecutors connected the murders to Findlay’s rejection of a relationship involving children.
Her defense attorneys disputed that explanation, emphasizing her mental health struggles, personal trauma and suicidal thoughts.
The exact psychological factors behind her actions remained contested, but Smith was convicted of murdering both boys.
What Did Tom Findlay Say During Susan Smith’s Trial?
Tom Findlay testified during Susan Smith’s criminal trial in July 1995.
He described their romantic relationship and explained why he had decided to end it.
His testimony included details about the letters exchanged shortly before the murders.
Findlay acknowledged that he had feelings for Smith but did not want to become a parent or stepfather.
He also described conversations about her marriage and the uncertainty surrounding their relationship.
The prosecution used his testimony to support its argument that Smith wanted to remove what she perceived as an obstacle to their romance.
Findlay’s appearance in court became one of the most discussed moments of the trial because it provided insight into Smith’s personal relationships before the killings.
Despite the public attention, Findlay was never charged in connection with the deaths of Michael and Alexander.
Was Susan Smith Married While Dating Tom Findlay?
Susan Smith was married to David Smith during part of her relationship with Tom Findlay.
Susan and David married in 1991 and welcomed two sons during their marriage.
Their relationship experienced serious difficulties, including periods of separation and disagreements.
Smith became involved with Findlay while her marriage was deteriorating.
During the trial, Findlay testified that he believed Susan was pursuing a divorce.
However, he later learned that her marital situation was more complicated than he had understood.
Following the murders, David Smith publicly expressed grief and disbelief after learning that his wife had killed their children.
The couple divorced in 1995.
David subsequently remarried and continued advocating for his sons during Susan’s parole proceedings.
Did Susan Smith Have a Relationship While in Prison?
Susan Smith’s romantic history has continued attracting attention during her imprisonment.
Her disciplinary record includes inappropriate relationships with prison employees, resulting in sanctions during the early years of her incarceration.
More recently, a former inmate named Tracey Thompson publicly claimed that she had a romantic relationship with Smith while they were incarcerated together.
Thompson alleged that their relationship lasted approximately four years.
She also expressed opposition to Smith’s release from prison.
However, these claims represent Thompson’s account and should not be treated as independently established details of Smith’s private life.
Reports have also described Smith communicating with men outside prison, some of whom expressed romantic interest in her.
There is no reliable public confirmation that Smith currently has a boyfriend, fiancé or husband.
What Happened at Susan Smith’s Parole Hearing?
Susan Smith appeared before the South Carolina parole board on November 19, 2026.
The hearing marked her second attempt to obtain release after serving more than three decades in prison.
She had previously been denied parole in November 2024.
During the hearing, Smith apologized for killing her sons and said she had changed during her incarceration.
She also challenged the prosecution’s longstanding argument that her romantic relationship was the reason she committed the murders.
Her former husband, David Smith, appeared before the board and strongly opposed her release.
He described the continuing pain of losing Michael and Alexander and argued that allowing their mother to leave prison would be unjust.
The parole board unanimously denied Smith’s request.
She remains incarcerated and will become eligible for another parole hearing in 2028.
Where Is Tom Findlay Now?
Tom Findlay has maintained a relatively private life since his involvement in Susan Smith’s murder trial.
Although his testimony remains part of the historical record, reliable public information about his current occupation, marriage or family circumstances is limited.
He has not been publicly identified as having any continuing romantic relationship with Smith.
His connection to the case remains primarily historical, involving the relationship that ended shortly before the murders.
For many people revisiting the case, Findlay’s testimony helps explain the prosecution’s theory of motive.
However, responsibility for the killings rests with Susan Smith, who was convicted and sentenced to life imprisonment.
Susan Smith’s former boyfriend, Tom Findlay, became a significant figure in the investigation because of their relationship and his decision to end it. His testimony helped prosecutors explain their theory of why Smith killed her children, although her defense challenged that interpretation. More than three decades later, Smith remains in prison, while Findlay has largely stayed away from public attention.